Monday, March 16, 2015

Ancient Babylonian Mathematics: Tablet VAT 8389

If the history of mathematics interests you, I highly recommend Jacques Sesiano's book “An Introduction to the History of Algebra“ (AMS, 2009). I particularly enjoyed the first chapter on ancient Babylonian algebra. There's one thing that I was really missing though... images of the original text. Digging just one of these images up sent me on something of a journey and sadly I can only use them for educational, non-profit purposes (which is why this is on my blog). The word "text" might give readers the wrong idea, so let me just throw this out there:
Photo credit: © Staatliche Museen zu Berlin – Museum of the Ancient Near East | Photo: Olaf M. Teßmer, May 2010 | USED WITH PERMISSION
What you're looking at is tablet VAT 8389 from the Museum of the Ancient Near East in Berlin, Germany. The tablet contains the solution to system of linear equations that today we'd write like this:
x + y = 1800
⅔∙x - ½∙y = 500
Such representation is anachronistic to say the least.

Today I'm going to pull out everything I know about this tablet: transliteration, literal and adapted translation, mathematical interpretation, and comparison with modern mathematics.

The Babylonians didn't have lined paper, so I've corrected that here:
Photo credit: © Staatliche Museen zu Berlin – Museum of the Ancient Near East | Photo: Olaf M. Teßmer, May 2010 | USED WITH PERMISSION | Edited by me in PowerPoint
Transliteration.
The following transliteration appears in Lengths, Widths, Surfaces: A Portrait of Old Babylonian Algebra and Its Kin (Springer, 2013) by Jens Høyrup. I am no expert in ancient pronunciation of ancient Babylonian cuneiform (my background is in chemical engineering...). This was hard to type and I am not positive I got all the characters right.

I-1           i-na bùr 4 še.gur am-ku-us
I-2           i-na bùr ša-ni-im 3 še.gur am-ku-us
I-3           še-um ugu še-in 8,20 i-ter
I-4           garim ĝar.ĝar-ma 30
I-5           garim en.nam
I-6           30 bu-ra-am ĝar.ra 20 še-am ša im-ku-sú ĝar.ra
I-7           30 bu-ra-am ša-ni-am ĝar.ra
I-8           15 še-am ša im-ku-sú
I-9           8,20 ša še-um ugu še-im i-te-ru ĝar.ra
I-10        ù 30 ku-mur-ri a.šà garim.mes ĝar.ra-ma
I-11        30 ku-mur-ri a.šà garim.meš
I-12        a-na ši-na ḫe-pé-ma 15
I-13        15 ù 15 a-di si-ni-šu ĝar.ra-ma
I-14        igi 30 bu-ri-im pu-tur-ma 2
I-15        2 a-na 20 še ša im-ku-su
I-16        íl 40 še-um lul a-na 15 ša a-di ši-ni-šu
I-16a      ta-aš-ku-nu
I-17        íl 10 re-eš-ka li-ki-il
I-18        igi 30 bu-ri-im ša-ni-im pu-tur-ma 2
I-19        2 a-na 15 še-im ša im-ku-sú
I-20        íl 30 š-um lul a-na 15 ša a-di ši-ni-šu
I-20a      ta-aš-ku-nu íl 7,30
I-21        10 ša re-eš-ka ú-ka-lu
I-22        ugu 7,30 mi-nam i-ter 2,30 i-ter
I-23        2,30 ša i-te-ru i-na 8,20
I-24        ša še-um ugu še-im i-te-ru
II-1         ú-sú-uḫ-ma 5,50 te-zi-ib
II-2         5,50 ša te-zi-bu
II-3         re-eš-ka li-ki-il
II-4         40 ta-ki-ir-tam ù 30 ta-ki-ir-tam
II-5         ĝar.ĝar-ma 1,10 i-gi-a-am ú-ul i-de
II-6         mi-nam a-na 1,10 lu-uš-ku-un
II-7         ša 5,50 ša re-eš-ka ú-ka-lu i-na-di-nam
II-8         5 ĝar.ra 5 a-na 1,10 íl
II-9         5,50 it-ta-di-kum
II-10       5 ša ta-aš-ku-nu i-na 15 ša a-di ši-ni-šu
II-11       ta-aš-ku-nu i-na iš-te-en ú-sú-uḫ
II-12       a-na iš-te-en sí-im-ma
II-13       iš-te-en 20 ša-nu-um 10
II-14       20 a.šà garim iš-te-at 10 a.ša garim ša-ni-tim
II-15       šum-ma 20 a.šà garim iš-te-at
II-16       10 a.šà garim ša-ni-tim še-ú-ši-na en.nam
II-17       igi 30 bu-ri-im pu-tur-ma 2
II-18       2 a-na 20 še-im ša im-ku-sú
II-19       íl 40 a-na 20 a.šà garim iš-te-at
II-20       íl 13,20 še-um ša 20 a.šà garim
II-21       igi 30 bu-ri-im ša-ni-im pu-ṭur-ma 2
II-22       2 a-na 15 še-im ša im-ku-sú íl 30
II-23       30 a-na 10 a.šà garim ša-ni-tim
II-24       íl 5 še-um ša 10 a.šà garim ša-ni-tim
II-25       13,20 še-um a.šà garim iš-te-at
II-26       ugu 5 še-im a.šà garim ša-ni-tim
II-27       mi-nam i-ter 8,20 i-ter

Literal Translation
Next is a word-for-word translation. It's worth mentioning that Babylonian numbers were written in sexagesimal (base 60). For clarity I've included the place value of numerals which the Babylonians inferred by context.
               
I-1           From a bur 04. kur of grain I have collected.
I-2           from a second bur 03. kur of grain I have collected.
I-3           grain over grain, 08,20. it went beyond
I-4           My plots I have accumulated: 30,00.
I-5           My plots what?
I-6           30,00. the bur, posit. 20,00. , the grain which he has collected, posit.
I-7           30,00. , the second bur, posit.
I-8           15,00. , the grain which he has collected
I-9           08,20. which the grain over the grain went beyond
I-10        and 30,00. the accumulation of the surfaces of the plots posit:
I-11        30,00. the accumulation of the surfaces of the plots
I-12        to two break: 15,00.
I-13        15,00. and 15,00. until twice posit:
I-14        Inverse 30,00. , of the bur, detach 00.00,02
I-15        00.00,02 to 20,00. , the grain which he has collected
I-16        raise, 00.40 the false grain; to 15,00. which until twice
I-16a      you have posited,
I-17        raise, 10,00. may your head hold!
I-18        Inverse 30,00. , of the second bur, detach 00.00,02
I-19        00.00,02 to 15,00. , the grain which he has collected
I-20        raise, 00.30 the false grain; to 15,00. which until twice
I-20a      you have posited, raise 07,30. .
I-21        10,00. which your head holds
I-22        over 07,30. what goes beyond? 02,30. it goes beyond
I-23        02,30. which it goes beyond, from 08,20.
I-24        which the grain over the grain goes beyond
II-1         tear out: 05,50. you leave
II-2         05,50. which you have left
II-3         may your head hold!
II-4         00.40, the change, and 00.30 the change,
II-5         accumulate 01.10 . The inverse I do not know.
II-6         What to 01.10 may I posit?
II-7         which 05,50. which you head holds gives me?
II-8         05,00. posit. 05,00. to 01.10 raise.
II-9         05,50. it gives to you.
II-10       05,00. which you have posited, from 15,00. which until twice
II-11       you have posited, from one tear out,
II-12       to one append:
II-13       The first is 20,00. , the second is 10,00.
II-14       20,00. is the surface of the first plot, 10,00. is the surface of the second plot
II-15       If 20,00. is the surface of the first plot,
II-16       10,00. the surface of the second plot, their grains what?
II-17       Inverse 30,00. , of the bur, detach 00,00.02 .
II-18       00,00.02 to 20,00. , the grain which he has collected,
II-19       raise 00.40 to 20,00. . The surface of the first plot,
II-20       raise, 13,20. . The grain of 20,00. , the surface of the meadow
II-21       Inverse 30,00. , of  the second bur, detach 00.00,02
II-22       00.00,02 to 15,00. the grain which he has collect, raise, 00.30
II-23       00.30 to 10,00. , the surface of the second plot
II-24       raise, 05,00. the grain of the surface of the second plot.
II-25       13,20. the grain of the surface of the first plot
II-26       over 05,00. the grain of the surface of the second plot
II-27       what goes beyond? 08,20. it goes beyond.

Adapted Translation
Between the strange grammar, the use of sexagesimal, lack of units (which if written, would have been long outdated [says the guy from the US...]), and ancient methodology, I can't make much of this without differing expertise. The following adapted translation is based on that found in Jacques Sesiano's book: “An Introduction to the History of Algebra“ (AMS, 2009).

"Bur" and "sar" are units of field area. 1 bur = 1800 sar. A sar is about 36 square meters.
"Kur" and "sila" are units of grain volume. 1 kur = 300 sila. A sila is about 1 liter.
      
I-1           The 1st field gave 4 kur for each bur (2/3 sila for each sar)
I-2           The 2nd field gave 3 kur for each bur (1/2 sila for each sar)
I-3           The 1st field gave 500 more sila than the 2nd
I-4           The sum of the fields' areas is 1 bur (1800 sar)
I-5           What is the area of each field?
I-6           The 1st field gave 1200 sila for every 1800 sar
I-7           The 2nd field gave 900 sila for every 1800 sar
I-8           ↑
I-9           The 1st field gave 500 more sila than the 2nd
I-10        The total area of the two fields is 1800 sar
I-11        ↑
I-12        1800/2 = 900
I-13        You now have two values of 900
I-14        (1800)^(-1) = (1/1800)
I-15        (1/1800) × 1200 = (2/3) "false grain"
I-16        (2/3) × 900 = 600 "hold"
I-16a      ↑
I-17        ↑
I-18        (1800)^(-1) = (1/1800)
I-19        (1/1800) × 900 = (1/2) "false grain"
I-20        (1/2) × 900 = 450
I-20a      ↑
I-21        600 - 450 = 150
I-22        ↑
I-23        500 - 150 = 350 "hold"
I-24        ↑
II-1         ↑
II-2         ↑
II-3         ↑
II-4         (2/3) + (1/2) = (7/6)
II-5         (7/6)^(-1) = unknown
II-6         (7/6) × z = 350
II-7         ↑
II-8         300 × (7/6) = 350, z = 300
II-9         ↑
II-10       900 + 300 = 1200, 900 - 300 = 600
II-11       ↑
II-12       ↑
II-13       The 1st field has an area of 1200 sar, The 2nd field has an area of 600 sar
II-14       ↑
II-15       ↑
II-16       What are the yields of each field?
II-17       (1800)^(-1) = (1/1800)
II-18       (1/1800) × 1200 = (2/3)
II-19       (2/3) × 1200  = 800 "grain of the 1st field"
II-20       ↑
II-21       (1800)^(-1) = (1/1800)
II-22       (1/1800) × 900 = (1/2)
II-23       (1/2) × 600 = 300 "grain of 2nd field"
II-24       ↑
II-25       The 1st field produced 800 sila
II-26       The 2nd field produced 300 sila
II-27       800 - 300 = 500

Mathematical Interpretation
To make sense of this I've prepared the following graphic. I've done my best to identify the major events in each part of the procedure.

Image Credit: Self (Power Point)
The Babylonians solved this problem by figuring out how far the area of each field deviated (steps B-G) from half of the total area (step A). Step H has the answer, and steps I-K verify this answer is correct.

Analysis of Method
Working backward from the described method of verification, we can use modern methods to determine the ancient methods. Here we call the deviation from midpoint "z" and reverse engineer its method of determination. How did the Babylonians figure this out? I can speculate until the cows come home... but rigorous answers have been lost to the sands of time.

Image Credit: Self

Modern Method
Here's how the math looks today after filtering through 4000 years of advancement by civilization after civilization, specifically tenth-c. BCE Assyria, the seventh-c. BCE Chaldeans, sixth-c. BCE Persia, fourth-c. BCE Greece, first-c. CE Rome, fifth-c. CE India., ninth-c. CE Arabia, and 11th-c. CE Europe. By the beginning of the scientific revolution (17th-c. CE Europe), the notation and methodology would have been recognizable as something like this:
                x + y = 1800
                ⅔∙x - ½∙y = 500

                y = 1800 – x
                ⅔∙x - ½∙(1800 - x) = 500
                ⅔∙x - 900 + ½∙x = 500
                (7/6)∙x = 1400
                x = 1200

                (1200) + y = 1800
                y = 600

Is our modern method better? Yes. To be fair, it has the advantage of contributions of nearly every great civilization of Eurasia over the last 4000 years. Let us hope these methods survive even the fall of our own civilization.

16 comments:

  1. I like how all of these discovery and ideas of basic Algebra, come down to Galois's theory, in the abstract realm of Modern Algebra. The key contributing factor to Galois's discovery of various equations, all are noted from predecessors of mathematicians, who all played a role in improving and rewriting Algebra. Galois tirelessly refers back to Gauss and Lagrange's works in the process of writing and composing existing equations, and finding it in a simple explanation, which to some may rather be complicated. I'd like how you reference the sources and restructure the ancient tablet to make Algebra more understandable.

    ReplyDelete
  2. You also can get some latest information on Real life importance of algebra

    ReplyDelete
  3. Nice Explanation of Content

    Get economics home tuition with Ziyyara as it provides one-to-one economics tutor online which is quite similar to the tutoring provided by an Economics home tutor.

    Visit Us:- https://ziyyara.in/home-tuition/online-home-tuition-for-economics
    Get Free Demo:- https://ziyyara.in/ad-contact
    Call Us for Free Demo:- +91-9654271931

    ReplyDelete
  4. Awesome Content

    Ziyyara’s Online home tuition for Accountancy comes in handy when a student needs instant help. We offer Accountancy tuition classes with the help of best accountancy tutors.

    Visit Us:- https://ziyyara.in/home-tuition/online-home-tuition-for-accountancy
    Call Us for Free Demo:- +91-9654271931
    Get Free Demo:- https://ziyyara.in/ad-contact

    ReplyDelete

  5. Awesome Content

    Ziyyara is providing business studies tuition at the comfort of your home. You just need good internet connectivity and a laptop to start your live online classes.

    Visit Us:- https://ziyyara.in/home-tuition/online-home-tuition-for-business-studies
    Get Free Demo:- https://ziyyara.in/ad-contact
    Call Us for Free Demo:- +91-9654271931

    ReplyDelete
  6. Nicely Explained

    Get Physics online tutor at Ziyyara and attend 1-to-1
    online physics tuition classes at an understanding of the same level as Physics and Maths home tutor offers.
    Get Free Demo:- https://ziyyara.in/ad-contact
    Call Us for Free Demo:- 9654271931
    Visit Us:- https://ziyyara.in/home-tuition/online-home-tuition-for-physics

    ReplyDelete
  7. Have Good Observation

    A race to find the best online coaching classes ends at Ziyyara. Get one-on-one live online home tuition classes from India’s best online home tutor at your convenience.

    Get Free Demo:- https://ziyyara.in/ad-contact
    Call Us for Free Demo:- +91-9654271931
    Visit Us:- https://ziyyara.in/home-tuition

    ReplyDelete
  8. Nice Content

    Get Professional Diploma In Internet Marketing After completing Internet Marketing Course in Delhi. Internet Marketing in Delhi is becoming one of the best skills. We at Caba Innovatives provide you with a written job Guarantee.


    Are you waiting for more Information?

    Visit us at, Address: E 79, Second Floor, South Extension I, New Delhi, Delhi 110049 Or Call Us:- 09811746259

    Must-Know:- https://www.caba.in/courses/digital-marketing-course

    ReplyDelete
  9. You have written nice Content!

    If you want to make your career in Web Designing then you should find a best Web Designing Institute to learn it, after learning web Web Designing you must be able to make creatives. The Designing industry is the biggest industry because today’s time is all about the presentation , infographic information.
    Address: E-80, 1st Floor, South Extension I, New Delhi, Delhi 110049 Phone: 09958635115

    Must Visit:- https://www.web-designing-course.in/

    ReplyDelete
  10. If you want to make your career in Web Development then you should do Web Development Courses to learn it, after learning Web Development, you must be able to develop websites. The Development industry is the biggest industry because today’s time is all about the presentation in the presence of the internet.

    Visit Us:- https://www.caba.in

    ReplyDelete
  11. Live best diploma courses in Delhi By Hand-picked Instructors and expertly crafted courses, designed for modern students and entrepreneurs.

    Must-Know:- https://www.diplomacourses.in/
    Phone:- 07827387200

    ReplyDelete
  12. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  13. Nice content, Thanks for sharing with us. Ziyyara is a leading online education platform that offers comprehensive tuition for GCSE classes. With Ziyyara, students can get access to personalized, one-to-one tuition from the comfort of their own home.
    For more info contact +91-9654271931 | UAE +971- 505593798 or visit Home Tuition For GCSE Classes

    ReplyDelete
  14. Thank you for providing such an informative blog. Choose our online tuition for history, at Ziyyara. With Ziyyara's tuition of History, you'll gain a solid foundation and develop critical thinking skills needed to excel. Don't miss out on this incredible opportunity – enroll now.
    Visit Ziyyara.com or contact us at +91 9654271931

    ReplyDelete